Chromatin Immunoprecipitation Troubleshooting ChIP Troubleshooting

By Ryan Hamnett, PhD

Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) is a technique that uses antibodies to isolate specific proteins and their target DNA binding sequences from a complex biological sample. Below is our troubleshooting guide to help solve any issues that might be encountered with a ChIP experiment.

Potential issue: Possible solution:
Target protein is not enriched at region of interest Check available literature to determine if target was expected at binding locus

Include positive and negative binding loci controls for target

Include positive control antibody to confirm that ChIP is working as expected
Target protein interacts with DNA weakly or indirectly Longer crosslinking may be required
N-ChIP protocol inappropriate for target N-ChIP is suitable for histone proteins, which have an extremely strong interaction with DNA. It is not suitable for proteins with weak binding properties
Insufficient starting sample Prepare a separate plate of cells to accurately determine cell number.

Increase number of cells used if target is low abundance
Incomplete cell lysis Try alternative buffers with a higher concentration of detergent, including separate cell and nuclear lysis buffers

Check lysis progression under a microscope

Include mechanical force in lysis step, such as a Dounce homogenizer
Degradation of sample occurred Perform all steps on ice or at 4°C

Include protease inhibitors in buffers
Post-translational modifications are being disrupted during procedure Include enzyme inhibitors for specific PTMs (e.g. acetylation) if they are relevant to the target protein (e.g. acetylated histone)
Samples were over- or under-crosslinked Optimize incubation time in 1% formaldehyde, usually between 10 and 30 minutes
DNA was not sufficiently fragmented, which can result in low precipitation and poor resolution Optimize sonication parameters and analyze results on an agarose gel. Keep concentration of cells and volume consistent

Optimize MNase concentration

Samples may have been over-crosslinked; decrease crosslinking time or optimize glycine addition to ensure that fixation is quenched
Poor quality DNA gel images Reduce the amount of DNA loaded onto the gel

Run 1-1.5% agarose gel and use a lower voltage (dependent on gel size)
Low affinity ChIP antibody Ensure antibody has been validated for ChIP

Try an alternative antibody, if available

Try a polyclonal antibody, particularly for X-ChIP in which epitopes may have been blocked

Increase antibody incubation time
Insufficient ChIP antibody Use 1-10 µg of ChIP antibody per 25 µg chromatin
Insufficient time allowed for antibody-antigen interaction Perform the immunoprecipitation step overnight at 4°C
Specific antibody binding is being disrupted by stringent washes Do not use a concentration of NaCl higher than 500 mM in wash buffer
Beads used were low quality or low affinity Ensure that Protein A or G is compatible with the ChIP antibody

Follow bead product datasheet for optimal volume of beads to antibody ratio

Do not freeze beads
Incomplete elution Elute at 65°C

Try alternative elution buffers, such as including 1% SDS
DNA binding to tubes Use siliconized or low retention tubes
Potential issue: Possible solution:
Non-specific binding to beads Include a pre-clearing step

Block beads with BSA and salmon sperm DNA

Use magnetic beads, which typically show reduced non-specific binding
Insufficient fragmentation of chromatin Optimize fragmentation (enzymatic or sonication) to achieve fragments of 200-750 bp. Optimization is necessary for each cell or tissue type

Reduce amount of material (cell/tissue) used

Reduce crosslinking time, which can interfere with fragmentation process
Insufficient washing Increase the number or stringency of washes by altering salt and detergent concentration
Potential issue: Possible solution:
Poor amplification of product Chromatin may be overfragmented; signal is diminished for amplicons of over 150 bp if chromatin is fragmented to mono-nucleosome length

Design primers to amplify a smaller (<150 bp) region

Add more DNA to the PCR reaction or increase the number of cycles

Optimize PCR conditions
No template reaction is showing product Clean work area and pipettes

Use aerosol-resistant pipette tips

Use PCR grade reagents
No amplification of “input” material Ensure that input sample has had crosslinks reversed and been treated with proteinase K and RNase A
High Ct values in qPCR Use more DNA to start
Potential issue: Possible solution:
DNA fragment size too large Optimize sonication parameters or MNase treatment
Side Menu Main Menu Contact Us 0Checkout
Top